How Did You Get Into The Field Of Property Tax Enforcement?
After law school, I was drawn to tax law because of its mechanical nature and unique topics. I initially didn’t focus on property law, but over time I specialized in property tax. I’ve been in this niche for about 19 years now, working in a small firm handling various aspects of property tax enforcement.
What Is The Current Tax Enforcement Process In Illinois?
In Illinois, if an owner fails to pay property taxes, the county treasurer can auction off the delinquency amount at an annual auction. Bidders, including individual property owners and institutional investors, bid a percentage rate they want to earn back. The maximum rate is 9%. If the property owner doesn’t pay back the lien, the successful bidder can petition for a tax deed to the property.
What Happens To The Property’s Equity, If Any, After A Tax Sale Under The Current System?
Currently, if a property is sold due to tax delinquency, any remaining equity after settling the tax debt is not returned to the homeowner. For example, if $100 in taxes is owed on a $100,000 property, and it is sold, the homeowner loses the remaining equity of $99,900. This is the system in Illinois and similar states.
What Is The Impact Of The Us Supreme Court Case Tyler V. Hennepin?
This 2023 case involved a Minnesota woman who lost her property over $15,000 in unpaid taxes. The county kept an additional $25,000 in equity after selling the property, which the Supreme Court ruled as an unconstitutional taking under the Fifth Amendment.
What Did The Seventh Circuit Court Of Appeals Decide About Illinois’s Tax Deed Sale System?
The court ruled that the issue arises when a tax deed is issued, and the tax buyer retains the property’s equity. The system itself isn’t unconstitutional until that point. If taxes are paid back in time, the system functions as intended to encourage tax payments.
What Is The Current Situation With Property Tax Enforcement In Illinois?
Since Tyler v. Hennepin, Illinois has stalled in making legislative changes. Judges hesitate to issue orders, and tax sales have been delayed. Several legislative proposals are in the works, but no changes have been enacted yet.
What Changes Are Being Proposed In Illinois’ With Regards To The Issue Of Property Tax Sales?
Proposals include keeping the surplus equity with property owners and potentially eliminating private investors’ roles, especially in Cook County. Some bills propose a sunset period, allowing private investments for a few more years before transferring the responsibility to the county.
What Trends Are Observed In Other States’ Responses To Tyler V. Hennepin?
Most states have implemented judicial auctions and continue to allow private investors. They ensure the surplus equity is returned to the homeowner, often through auction processes that better reflect market values.
What Is The Significance Of The Pung V. Isabella County Case?
This Michigan case addresses the method of calculating surplus equity—whether it should be based on auction prices or fair market value. The Supreme Court’s decision could influence how Illinois and other states reform their systems.
What Are You Advising Transactional And Title Insurance Attorneys Right Now?
Attorneys should conduct thorough investigations into properties with delinquent taxes, as stalled cases may still have active liens. It’s crucial to verify tax redemption and ensure no issues remain post-closing.
What Is Your Advice For Potential Investors In Illinois Tax Deeds And Sales?
Given the current legal uncertainties and potential liabilities, it’s prudent to avoid investing in tax deeds until the legislature provides clarity. Investors risk buying into legal challenges and liabilities during this transitional period.

